The Fusion of Democracy and Racism: An Evaluation of the Regimes of Israel and the Apartheid South Africa

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor of Political Science, University of Mazandaran

2 B.A. Student of Political Science, University of Mazanadaran

10.22080/jpir.2025.28146.1409

Abstract

Democracy and racism are founded on ideas that, in theory, are in opposition to one another. However, in contemporary times, we have witnessed regimes that, despite being established on liberal democratic structures, have implemented racist beliefs on a wide scale. In this context, the question arises: how can this coexistence of contradictory elements (democracy and racism) be analyzed? The article hypothesizes that while democracy, as a method of governance, is based on a system of political equality and the ethics of compromise among different political, economic, and socio-cultural groups, its inclusiveness and flexibility may be limited to the insiders. This means its political equality and compromise ethics do not necessarily extend to the "absolute other" (different races or identities). To prove this hypothesis, the present research departs from the dichotomy of "ethnic/cultural nation and political nation" to explain "how the modern form of governance coexists with pre-modern normative content," aiming to provide a theoretical framework for understanding the hybrid phenomenon of the coexistence of democracy and racism within a political regime. As a case study, the research focuses on the regimes of Israel and the Apartheid South Africa. The research method is descriptive-analytical, and the data collection is based on library-based studies.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

- احمدی، حمید (1400). سیاست و حکومت در خاورمیانه (غرب آسیا) و شمال آفریقا، تهران: نی.
- اندرسون، لینه (1401). الفبای دموکراسی، ترجمۀ پرویز رهبری‌مقدم، تهران: کویر.
- باربیه، موریس (1383). مدرنیته سیاسی، ترجمۀ عبدالوهاب احمدی، تهران: آگه.
- برتون، رولان (1387). قوم‌شناسی سیاسی، ترجمۀ ناصر فکوهی، تهران: نی، چاپ سوم.
- بوبو، لارنس (1397). «تعارض گروهی، پیش‌داوری و تناقض‌های میان نگرش‌های نژادی معاصر»، در: روان‌شناسی سیاسی، ویراستۀ جان تی جاست و جیم سیدانیوس، ترجمۀ محمدرضا جلالی و محمد سعدی، تهران: پژوهشگاه فرهنگ، هنر و ارتباطات، 743- 693.
- تورن، آلن (1399). دموکراسی چیست؟، ترجمۀ سلمان صادقی‌زاده، تهران: ثالث.
- ریچ، برنارد (1394). «اسرائیل»، در: سیاست و حکومت در خاورمیانه و شمال آفریقا، ویراستۀ مارک گازیروسکی، ترجمۀ عسگر قهرمان‌پور، تهران: امیرکبیر، 482-429.
- سیدمن، گی (1392). «آفریقای جنوبی: مبارزه علیه آپارتاید»، در: مطالعاتی نظری، تطبیقی و تاریخی در باب انقلاب‌ها، ویراسته: جک گلدستون، ترجمۀ محمدتقی دلفروز، تهران: کویر، چاپ سوم، 434-421.
- شیخ­الاسلامی، محمدحسن؛ شیراوند، صارم (1392). «بررسی تطبیقی گفتمان آپارتاید در آفریقای جنوبی با اسرائیل»، فصل­نامۀ تحقیقات سیاسی و بین­المللی، 16 (5): 81-49.
- هیوود، اندرو (1395). مفاهیم کلیدی در علم سیاست، ترجمۀ حسن سعیدکلاهی و عباس کاردان، تهران: انتشارات علمی و فرهنگی، چاپ سوم.
 
- Barnes, J. J. (2019). “A Different Apartheid: Structural, Legal, and Discursive Foundations for Comparing South Africa and Israel”. Relating Worlds of Racism: Dehumanisation, Belonging, and the Normativity of European Whiteness, 245-269.
- Battersby-Lennard, J. (2009). “Apartheid/ Post-Apartheid”, In Kitchin, R., & Thrift, N. (2009). International encyclopedia of human geography. Elsevier.
- Baume, S., & Novak, S. (Eds.). (2020). Compromises in democracy. Palgrave Macmillan.
- Bonner, P. (2011). “South African society and culture, 1910–1948”. In Ross, R., Mager, A. K., & Nasson, B. (Eds.) , The Cambridge History of South Africa: Volume 2, 1885–1994, (pp. 254-318) Cambridge University Press.
- Charton, N. (1975). “English‐speaking white elites in South African politics”. Politikon: South African Journal of Political Studies, 2(2), 115-128.
- Coates, R. D. (2011). “Covert racism in the US and globally”. In Covert Racism (pp. 239-265). Brill.
- De Benoist, A. (1999). “What is racism?”. Telos, 1999 (114), 11-48.
- Dowty, A. (1999). “Is Israel democratic? Substance and semantics in the ‘ethnic democracy’ debate”. Israel studies, 4(2), 1-15.
- Dubow, S. (2024). “Apartheid in South Africa and Israel/Palestine: A Case of Convergent Evolution?”. Palestine/Israel Review, 1(2).
- Dvorin, E. P. (1951). “The theory of apartheid: Nationalist racial policy in the Union of South Africa”. Western Political Quarterly, 4(1), 32-47.
- Elias, S. (2015). “Racism, overt”. The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of race, ethnicity, and nationalism, 1-3.
- Erasmus, Z. (2000). “Recognition through pleasure, recognition through violence: Gendered colored subjectivities in South Africa”. Current sociology, 48(3), 71-85.
- Erikson, S. (1973). “An American Looks at South Africa: A Hybrid of Democracy and a Police State”. Journal of Thought, 106-117.
- Fischer, S. (2016). “Two patterns of modernization: An analysis of the ethnic issue in Israel”. Israel studies review, 31(1), 66-85.
- Fish, J., & Syed, M. (2020). “Racism, discrimination, and prejudice”. The encyclopedia of child and adolescent development, 1-12.
- Gavison, R. (1999). “Jewish and democratic? A rejoinder to the "ethnic democracy" debate”. Israel Studies, 4(1), 44-72.
- Greenstein, R. (2015). Israel: Where Do the Mizrahim Fit in?
- Guetzkow, J., & Ben-Zvi, K. (2017). “From ‘subcultures’ to ‘toolkits’: ethnicity and violence in Israeli prisons”. Social forces, 95(3), 1237-1259.
- Hasan, D. R. (2008). “The Unitary, Democratic State and the Struggle Against Apartheid in Palestine–Israel”. Holy Land Studies, 7(1), 81–94.
- Hofnung, M. & Wattad, M. S. (2021) “The Judicial Branch in Israel”. In Hazan, R. Y., Dowty, A., Hofnung, M., & Rahat, G. (Eds.). (2021). The Oxford handbook of Israeli politics and society. (317-330) Oxford University Press, USA.
- Kaufman, S. J. (2015). “The End of Apartheid in South Africa”. In Nationalist passions. Cornell University Press, 176-208.
- Kenig, O. (2021). “The Executive Branch in Israel”. In Hazan, R. Y., Dowty, A., Hofnung, M., & Rahat, G. (Eds.). (2021). The Oxford handbook of Israeli politics and society. (283-299) Oxford University Press.
- Mahler, G. (2021). “The ‘Constitutional’ system of Israel”. In Hazan, R. Y., Dowty, A., Hofnung, M., & Rahat, G. (Eds.). (2021). The Oxford handbook of Israeli politics and society. (268-281) Oxford University Press.
- Meierhenrich, J. (2008). The legacies of law: Long-run consequences of legal development in South Africa, 1652–2000. Cambridge University Press.
- Meir-Glitzenstein, E. (2020). “Mizrahim in the big city: an inside look at the social and cultural world of middle-class Iraqi immigrants in 1950s and 1960s Israel”. Journal of Modern Jewish Studies, 19(2), 119-142.
- Molavi, S. C. (2013). Stateless citizenship: The Palestinian-Arab citizens of Israel. Brill.
- Morlino, L. (2003). “What is a ‘good’democracy? Theory and the case of Italy”. South European Society and Politics, 8 (3), 1-32.
- Neuberger, B. (2019). “Democratic and anti-democratic roots of the Israeli political system”. Israel Studies Review, 34(2), 55-74.
-Peteet, J. (2016). “The work of comparison: Israel/ Palestine and apartheid”. Anthropological Quarterly, 247-281.
- Posel, D. (2011). “The apartheid project, 1948–1970”. In Ross, R., Mager, A. K., & Nasson, B. (Eds.) , The Cambridge History of South Africa: Volume 2, 1885–1994, (pp. 319-368) Cambridge University Press.
- Pypers, E., & Pothier, M. (2015). “South Africa’s parliamentary system: From Westminster to hybrid”. Briefing Paper, 380.
- Regan, B. (2008). “The State of Israel and the apartheid regime of South Africa in comparative perspective”. Holy Land Studies, 7(2), 201-212.
- Rostbøll, C. F. (2017). “Compromise and toleration: Responding to disagreement”. In Compromise and disagreement in contemporary political theory (pp. 17-33). Routledge.
- Rouhana, N. N., Rouhana, N. M., & Huneidi, S. S. (2017). “The Psychopolitical Foundations of Ethnic Privileges in the Jewish State”. Israel and Its Palestinian Citizens: Ethnic Privileges in the Jewish State, 3-35.
- Sharabi, M. (2014). “The relative centrality of life domains among Jews and Arabs in Israel: The effect of culture, ethnicity, and demographic variables”. Community, Work & Family, 17(2), 219-236.
- Smooha, S. (2002). “The model of ethnic democracy: Israel as a Jewish and democratic state”. Nations and nationalism, 8(4), 475-503.
- Southall, R. (2000). “The state of democracy in South Africa”. Journal of Commonwealth & Comparative Politics, 38(3), 147-170.
- Stebbins, R. A. (2017). From humility to hubris among scholars and politicians: Exploring expressions of self-esteem and achievement. Emerald Publishing Limited.
- The South African Judiciary (2017). SA Judiciary Booklet, Judiciary Publications.
- Wieviorka, M. (1995). The arena of racism. Sage Publication.
- Yiftachel O. (2023). “Deepening apartheid: The political geography of colonizing Israel/Palestine”. Frontiers in Political Science. Jan 11
- Yiftachel, O. (2006). Ethnocracy: Land and identity politics in Israel/Palestine. University of Pennsylvania Press.
- Zreik, R., & Dakwar, A. (2020). “What's in the apartheid analogy? Palestine/Israel refracted”. Theory & Event, 23(3), 664-705.
Journal of Politics and International Relations
Volume 8, Issue 15
August 2025
Pages 189-222

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics