Document Type : Original Article
Author
Associate Professor in International Relations, Department of Political Sciences, Faculty of Economic and Social Sciences, Bu-Ali University, Hamedan, Iran
10.22080/jpir.2022.24151.1304
Abstract
Iran’s nuclear program has been a central security concern for Israel over the past two decades. In reaction to this threat, Israel has conducted a multifaceted drive to block it, one of which is planning and enforcement a complex psychological warfare to block it from summer 2002(disclosing the program) to July 2015(signing JCPOA). This article seeks to understand the complex psychological warfare in the past three decades by using the process research method and offers recommendations for confronting it. The basic question is, what are the special features of Israel's psychological war against Iran's nuclear program? The main hypothesis is that Israel's psychological war is designed to impress the authorities of Tehran and Washington by making the scenario of a military attack against Iran's nuclear facilities look serious. The first motif was provoking anxiety about threat of Iranian nuclear project; the second emphasized the other threats that the Iranian regime poses, chief among them its aggressive policy, which includes involvement in terrorism and extensive activity to develop long range missiles; the third was the threat of Israel military attack on Iran’s nuclear facilities during 2010-2012; and the fourth from 2013 onwards, dealt with the negotiations between the world powers and Iran which had founded the ground for withdrawing Trump from JCPOA in 2018. Part two concentered on assessment of Israel challenges in psychological warfare against Iran’s Nuclear Program, especially under the experience of nuclear negotiations and after the signing JCPOA. In the end, some proper countermeasures would be offered.
Keywords
البرزیدعوتی، هادی و اکبر نصراللهی (تابستان 1397) «تحلیل روندها و پیشرانهای مؤثر بر خبر صدا و سیما در 5 سال آینده»، فصل‌نامه‌ی پژوهشهای ارتباطی، سال بیستوپنجم، شماره‌ی 2(پیاپی 94)94: 127-103.
حافظیان، محمدحسین (زمستان 1388) «ایران در خاورمیانه: روندهای آینده‌ی منطقه»، مطالعات اوراسیای مرکزی، شماره‌ی 5: 78-61.
مینایی، حسین؛ حاجیانی، ابراهیم؛ دهقان، حسین و فروزنده جعفرزاده (تابستان 1395) «تعیین پیشرانهای اصلی دیپلماسی دفاعی ج.ا ایران در سطوح منطقهای و بینالمللی»، فصل‌نامه‌ی آیندهپژوهی دفاعی. دوره‌ی 1، شماره‌ی 1: 26-7.
-Aaron Kalman, “Israel Used 17 Tons of Explosives to Destroy Syrian Reactor in 2007,” The Time of Israel, (September 10, 2012). From: www.timesofisrael.com/israel-uses-17-tons-of-explosives-to-destroy-syrian-reactor/.
-Alon, Gideon (December 1, 2005) “Director of Military Intelligence: After March 2006 there Will be No More Point in a Diplomatic Effort regarding the Iranian Nuclear Program,” Haaretz. [In Hebrew].
-Altman, Yair (November 25, 2013). “Netanyahu: Iran Has Received Written Approval to Violate UN Decisions,” Walla News. From: https://bit.ly/2tAErLB [in Hebrew].
-Arutz Sheva poll (April 18, 2012).
-Azoulay, Orly(June 22, 2006) “Prime Minister Olmert: Within a Few Months, Iran Will Be Able to Put Together a Nuclear Bomb,” Yediot Ahronot, [in Hebrew].
-Barak, Ehud (November 2011). “If I Were Iranian, I Would Probably Want Nuclear Weapons,” Bloomberg reported in Ynet on November 17, 2017. From: https://bit.ly/2E6bnjX [in Hebrew].
-Barak, Ehud (April 27, 2017). Interview with Nahum Barnea: “Why We Didn’t Bomb Iran”. Yediot Ahronot. From: https://bit.ly/2VaiIG0 [in Hebrew].
-Benhorin, Yitzhak (February 2, 2012). “Panetta Believes that Israel Will Attack Iran by June 2012,” Ynet. From: https://bit.ly/2IzwUqL [in Hebrew].
-Benn, Aluf (March 15, 2012). “Benjamin Netanyahu Sends Emergency Reserve Call-up to Himself and the Public,” Haaretz. From: https://bit.ly/2GZrl2D [in Hebrew].
-Benn, Aluf (March 6, 2012). “Netanyahu Nearing War with Iran,” Haaretz. [in Hebrew]. Rosner, Shmuel (April 25, 2012). “Playing the Holocaust Card,” New York Times.
-Bergman, Ronen (July 8, 2005). “Last Stop on the Way to the Bomb,” Yediot Ahronot, [in Hebrew].
-Board of Governors (GOV/2011/65) (November 18, 2011). “Implementation of the NPT Safeguards Agreement and Relevant Provisions of Security Council Resolutions in the Islamic Republic of Iran”. From: https://bit.ly/1Nsifrx.
-Bush, George. W (2010). Decision Points. New York: Crown Publishing. pp. 418-19.
-Bryan, Bender, “How John Kerry Opened a Secret Channel to Iran,” Boston Globe. From: https://bit.ly/2SZpQJ3.
-Chairman of Joint Chiefs of Staff (February 18, 2012). “An Israeli Attack Will Not Achieve its End”. Ynet. From: https://bit.ly/2Ep58ZR.
-Charles D. Freilich (2018) .“Israeli National Security: A New Strategy for an Era of Change”. London. Oxford.
- “Director of Military Intelligence: ‘Iran Has Not Yet Decided Whether to Develop Nuclear Weapons,’” (February 2, 2012). Walla News. From: https://bit.ly/2U5hpbg [in Hebrew].
-Evental, Udi (2006) “The United States and the Iranian Nuclear Challenge: Inadequate Alternatives, Problematic Choices,” Strategic Assessment 9, No. 1 (2006): 24-32. From: https://bit.ly/2lVmvuO.
-Fuchs, Camil (March 26, 2012). Poll by the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs: “Majority of Israeli Citizens Support Attacking Iran” [in Hebrew].
-Goldberg, Jeffrey (September 2010). “The Point of No Return,” The Atlantic. From: https://bit.ly/2BP40NH.
-Hafazi, Parisa (January 11, 2006). “Blair Urges UN to Consider Action on Iran,” Reuters.
Harel, Amos (January 22, 2006). “Shaul Mofaz: Israel Must Prepare to Defend Itself against the Iranian Nuclear Threat, with All This Entails,” Haaretz. [in Hebrew].
-Herzog, Mike (April 29, 2018) “The Destruction of the Syrian Reactor – Another Look,” Haaretz From: https://bit.ly/2HOr6FW [in Hebrew].
-Hirschberg, Peter (November 14, 2006). “Netanyahu: The Year is 1936 and Iran is Germany,” Haaretz. [in Hebrew].
-Ignatius, David (7 June, 2016). The Omani 'Back Channel' to Iran and the Secrecy Surrounding the Nuclear Deal. Washington Post. From: https://www.belfercenter.org/node/89179.
-Kam, Ephraim (2004). From Terrorism to Nuclear Bombs: The Significance of the Iranian Threat. Tel Aviv: Ministry of Defense Publishing House. [in Hebrew].
-Kam, Ephraim (2008). “Military Action against Iran: The Iranian Perspective”. Strategic Assessment 11, no. 2 (2008): 97-106. From: https://bit.ly/2kUH2iT.
-Landau Emily & Shimon, Stein (August 18, 2015). “Israel and the Nuclear Deal with Iran: Chronicle of a Failure Foretold?” INSS Insight No. 735. From: https://bit.ly/2ku6WtG.
-Landler, Mark (June 7, 2016), Alter Egos: Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama and the Twilight Struggle over American Power. Ebury Publishing.; Ignatius, David (June 7, 2016) “The Omani ‘Back Channel’ and the Secrecy Surrounding the Nuclear Deal,” Belfer Center. From: https://bit.ly/2GGU2C4.
-Leibowitz-Dar, Sara (January 14, 2011). “Like Her Scream?” Maariv, [in Hebrew].
-Leon, Eli (November 18, 2013) “Amidror: Israel Can Attack Iran Alone,” Israel Hayom. From:
https://bit.ly/2IAmE1w [in Hebrew].
-Lieberman, Avigdor (August 5, 2016). “The Nuclear Deal with Iran – Is like the Munich Agreement with Nazi Germany,” Ynet. From: https://bit.ly/2Iz9cLj [in Hebrew].
-Lior, Gad (July 10, 2001) “Defense Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer: ‘Within 4 Years Iran Will Threaten Israel with Nuclear Weapons,’ Yediot Ahronot, [in Hebrew];
-Melman, Yossi (March 19, 2009), “Between Two Nuclear Clocks,” Haaretz. From: https:// bit.ly/2STAL6O [in Hebrew].
-Maariv poll (August 10, 2012).
-Nathan, Guttmann (May 14, 2005). “Sharon: Israel is Not Considering an Attack on Iran,” Walla News. [in Hebrew].
-Netanyahu, Benjamin (October 1, 2013). “Israel ‘is Prepared to Act Alone against Iran,’ Netanyahu Says”. The National. From:
-Netanyahu, Benjamin (March 6, 2012). “Netanyahu’s speech at the AIPAC convention. Wikisource. From: https://bit.ly/2HZzVjV.
-Netanyahu, Benjamin (February 4, 2015): “ISIL Burns People and in Iran They Hang Them,” Channel 10 News. From: https://bit.ly/2GUXSqu.
-Noda, Yoshihiko (February 15, 2012). “Don’t Attack Iran – It is a Dangerous Act,” Ynet. From: https://bit.ly/2TfAr1q; Juppé, Alain (November 6, 2011). The French Foreign Minister declared that an attack on Iran “would destabilize the entire region,” in Reuters, “France: An Attack on Iran would Upset the Stability of the Entire Region,” Channel 13 News. From: https://bit.ly/2SoTuSw.
-Obama, Barak (June 5, 2009). “You Have the Ability to Create a New World”. Haaretz. From: https://bit.ly/2BSOfVT [in Hebrew].
- “Obama AIPAC Speech,” (March 4, 2012). The Guardian. From:
https://bit.ly/2STiLta.
-Oren, Amir (February 3, 2010). “American Intelligence: Iran Can Develop Nuclear Weapons but Has Not Yet Decided to Do so,” Haaretz. From: https: //bit.ly/2Dd0JXW. [in Hebrew].
- “Panetta Warns Israel on Consequences of Iran Military Strike” (November 18, 2011). Fox News. From: https://fxn.ws/2XgyMYZ.
-Peace Index (August 2015, September 9, 2015). From:
https://bit.ly/2XkH6a0 [in Hebrew].
-Perry, Dan and Federman, Josef (February 5, 2012) “Just a Bluff? Fear Grows of Israeli Attack on Iran,” AP.
-Pfeffer,Anshel(December 14, 2009). “Director of Military Intelligence: The Nuclear Technology Clock in Iran has Almost Completed its Rotation,” Haaretz. From: https:// bit.ly/2SmXKlw [in Hebrew].
-Public diplomacy video of the Prime Minister’s Office (July 1, 2015). Form: https://bit. ly/2GGT9JK.
-Ravid, Barak (December 11, 2006). “Ahmadinejad Denies the Holocaust in Order to Destroy Us,” Maariv. From:
https://bit.ly/2GDwLB3 [in Hebrew].
-Ravid, Barak (July 14, 2015), “Netanyahu: After the Agreement, Israel Is Not Committed to the Deal,” Haaretz. From: https://bit.ly/2NlRkCx [in Hebrew].
-Ravid, Barak (March 3, 2015). “Netanyahu at Congress: The Deal with Iran Is Terrible and Will Lead to War,” Haaretz. From:
https://bit.ly/2SispR7 [in Hebrew].
-Regev, Amos (March 15, 2012). “Difficult, Daring, Possible,” Israel Hayom, [in Hebrew].
-Rise, Suzan (February 25, 2015). Interview with Charlie Rose. Ynet. From: https://bit.ly/2Vg26Nf.
-Shavit, Ari (August 10, 2012). “The Decision Maker Warns: We Can’t Trust the United States to Attack Iran in Time,” Haaretz. From:
https://bit.ly/2ViD1RZ [in Hebrew].
-Shavit, Ari) September 28, 2012 (. “Israel Facing the Dilemma of its Life,” Haaretz. From:
https://bit.ly/2Iy4wp7 [in Hebrew].
-Sherman, Wendy (September 2018). “How We Got the Iran Deal,” Foreign Affairs. From:
-Shine, Sima (2018). “The Intelligence Challenges of the Iranian Nuclear Issue,” in Shmuel Even and David Siman-Tov (Eds), The Challenges of the Israeli Intelligence Community. Tel Aviv: Institute for National Security Studies (INS) [in Hebrew].
-Sobelman, Daniel “Restraining an Ally: Israel, the US and Iran Nuclear Program, 2011-2012,” Texas National Service Review 1, no. 4 (August 2018). From: https://bit. ly/2XtjTma
-Sobelman, Danial (August, 2018). “Restraining an Ally: Israel, the United States, and Iran’s Nuclear Program, 2011–2012.”. Taxes National Security Review. Vol.1. Issue 4.
-Solomon, Jay (June 28, 2015). “Secret Dealing with Iran Led to Nuclear Talks,” Wall Street Journal.
-Somfalvi, Attila (February 27, 2012). “Sources in Jerusalem against the US: ‘They Are Waging a Campaign to Prevent Us from Attacking,’” Ynet. From:
https://bit. ly/2tyuEpg [in Hebrew].
-Stein, Shimon (2010). “The European Union and the Iranian Nuclear Crisis,” in A Nuclear Iran: Confronting the Challenge on the International Arena, eds. Tamar Malz Ginzburg and Moty Cristal, Memorandum No. 103. Tel Aviv: Institute for National Security Studies. [in Hebrew].
- “The Washington Files” (January 17, 2006). State Department Briefery; “Cheney Warns of Iran Nuclear Threat” (January 21, 2005). Washington Post.
Uvda. Mako website (November 5, 2012). From: https://bit.ly/2GFN2Fu [in Hebrew].
-Weitz, Gidi (January 14, 2015). Haaretz, From: https://bit.ly/2Ep2bsf [in Hebrew].
-Yadlin, Amos (March 8, 2009). “Iran Has Crossed the Nuclear Threshold,” Yet. From:
https://bit.ly/2BP8XWR [in Hebrew].
)